Haven Health Plans 970.505.9652 Schedule an Appointment

Penalties

Yes, Medicare can penalize you. Here is exactly how, and how not to be.

Late enrollment penalties are not a fine you pay once. Two of the three are added to your premium every month for as long as you have that coverage. Almost every one of them is avoidable, and avoiding them is entirely a matter of knowing the calendar. Nobody sends you that calendar, so here it is.

Ask your local pharmacist about usWe do not pick plans around pharmaciesYour doctors checked by nameAsk what a plan pays us
Reviewing Medicare premium and penalty figures
Started by pharmacists Covered is not the same as affordable. A pharmacist knows the difference.

The three penalties

They work differently, and only one of them ends.

Figures below are 2026 amounts. Medicare updates them annually, so confirm the current year before relying on the arithmetic.

PenaltyHow it is calculatedHow long you pay it
Part B10% added for each full 12-month period you could have had Part B and did not enroll. Calculated on the standard premium, which is $202.90 per month in 2026.For as long as you have Part B. This one is permanent.
Part D1% of the national base beneficiary premium, $38.99 in 2026, for every full month you went without creditable drug coverage. Rounded to the nearest 10 cents.For as long as you have Medicare drug coverage, even if you switch plans.
Part AA flat 10% increase, not 10% per year. Only applies to the small number of people who do not qualify for premium-free Part A.Twice the number of years you could have had Part A and did not sign up. This one does end.

The one people ask about most

The Part B penalty is permanent, and partial years do not count.

Your Part B premium goes up 10 percent for every full twelve-month period you could have had Part B and did not take it. Not a one-time charge. Every month, for as long as you have Part B.

  • Medicare's example: two full years late is 20 percent. On the 2026 standard premium of $202.90 that is an extra $40.58 a month, or $243.50 in total.
  • It counts full twelve-month periods only, so a 23-month delay is 10 percent and not 20. One month decides it.
  • You generally will not owe it if you qualify for a Special Enrollment Period.
  • Enrolling in a Medicare Savings Program also eliminates the Part B penalty. This is real and almost never mentioned.
  • Delaying Part B while covered by a large employer group plan does not create a penalty.

The quiet one

The Part D penalty starts after 63 days without drug coverage.

Not two months. Not a grace period until the end of the year. Sixty-three consecutive days without Medicare drug coverage or other creditable coverage, and the penalty attaches.

  • The trigger is a day count, not a month count. Sixty-three consecutive days is the legal test.
  • It is 1 percent of the national base beneficiary premium, $38.99 in 2026, for each full month you went uncovered.
  • Medicare's example: 14 uncovered months is 14 percent, about $5.50 a month on top of whatever your plan costs.
  • It looks small. It is permanent, it follows you across plan changes, and it grows the longer the gap ran.
  • You will not owe it while you receive Extra Help. Note the word while. If Extra Help eligibility ends, the penalty can apply again.
  • Having creditable drug coverage the whole time is the clean way to avoid it entirely.

Creditable coverage

Keep the letter. It is the document that defeats the penalty.

Creditable coverage means coverage expected to pay, on average, at least as much as Medicare drug coverage. When you join a Medicare drug plan it may mail you a form asking whether you had it. Miss that deadline and the penalty is assessed as though you never did.

  • Commonly creditable: current or former employer or union drug coverage, TRICARE, the Department of Veterans Affairs, and Indian Health Service.
  • Also commonly creditable: the Federal Employees Health Benefits Program, qualified State Pharmaceutical Assistance Programs, and certain Medigap policies.
  • If you are not sure whether your coverage counts, the plan or employer that provides it can tell you in writing. Ask for that in writing.

If you already have one

A Part D penalty can be appealed, and there is a clock on it.

If your plan says you owe a Part D penalty and you think it is wrong, ask for a reconsideration. It is decided by Medicare's independent review contractor, not by your plan. The decision usually comes within 90 days.

  • Deadline: 60 days from the date on the penalty letter. Do not sit on it.
  • Send the form to the Independent Review Entity as instructed, not back to your plan.
  • Include proof of the prior coverage. A copy of the creditable coverage notice is the strongest evidence you can attach.
  • This process is for Part D. Bring us a Part B penalty question and we will help you figure out where it actually goes.

Not a penalty, and often confused with one

IRMAA is an income surcharge, not something you did wrong.

Above a certain income you pay an adjustment on top of your Part B and Part D premiums. This one is not a late enrollment penalty, and signing up on time does not avoid it.

It can be reconsidered though, and that is a form rather than an appeal.

  • 2026 thresholds begin above $109,000 individual and $218,000 filing jointly, based on 2024 income.
  • A life-changing event lets you request a new determination without filing a formal appeal.
  • Qualifying events: retirement, a work reduction, marriage, divorce, the death of a spouse, or a pension change.
  • Most people who qualify never file it. That is the whole problem.
  • If you retired recently and your Medicare premium looks high, this is very likely why, and it is very likely fixable.

Help that erases penalties

Extra Help and Medicare Savings Programs do more than most people know.

Two programs, both widely underclaimed. Both worth checking even if you assume your income is too high, because states do not all count income and resources the same way.

  • Extra Help 2026: income up to $23,940 for an individual, $32,460 for a married couple. Resource limits $18,090 and $36,100.
  • It takes your drug plan premium and deductible to zero, and stops the Part D late enrollment penalty being charged while you have it.
  • A Medicare Savings Program can pay your Part B premium outright, and it eliminates the Part B penalty.
  • Do not disqualify yourself on the numbers. You may still qualify in Colorado even above the federal limits.
  • Full-benefit Medicaid, state help with Part B premiums, or SSI payments qualify you for Extra Help automatically.
  • Ask us to check both. It takes one conversation and it is the highest-value fifteen minutes on this whole website.

What people say

In their words, not ours.

5.0 from 5 Google reviews

I have referred many patients from the clinic where I work who either lack insurance coverage or do not have adequate benefits, and Juan Carpenter has consistently made a meaningful difference in their lives.
Yadira S. · Google Referring clinic staff
We appreciate Juan's expertise and pleasant manner while exploring all the details of Medicare coverage.
Gregg M. · Google
Juan was very informative and extremely helpful.
Lynn H. · Google
Juan is great to work with. Very knowledgeable, works with you to find the best possible plan! Highly recommend!
David P. · Google

Why Haven

Why people end up here.

Whether a drug is covered is the easy question. What the plan does with it after that is where the year gets expensive, and that detail is a pharmacist's daily work.

Ask around first

Ask the pharmacist you already see.

Haven was started by the pharmacists at Good Day Pharmacy. So you can check us out before you ever pick up the phone. Not many people in this business can say that.

The fair question

We do not pick plans around pharmacies.

It is fair to wonder. We do not. If the best plan for your medications means filling somewhere else, we will tell you so. The only time a pharmacy comes into it is if you ask us to keep yours.

Read like a pharmacist

Covered is not the same as affordable.

A plan can list your medication and still cost you much more than the plan next to it. It comes down to tiers, limits, and prior authorizations. That is a pharmacist's daily work, and it is where most of the money hides.

Pharmacist-run

We have been on the other end of these plans.

Pharmacists are the ones who tell you what your prescription costs today. We did that for years. Then we got licensed, so the hard conversation could happen in October instead of January.

Doctors by name

We check your providers, not just the network in general.

Not a vague promise that most plans cover most doctors. We look up your specific physicians and specialists in front of you, before any plan gets named.

Local first, not local only

Northern Colorado is home.

Greeley, Fort Collins, Loveland, Windsor and the towns around them are where we live. We also reach Grand Junction, Palisade and Colorado Springs, and we are licensed in 25 states, so a move or a parent out of state is no trouble.

The best introductions

What the pharmacy relationships are actually for.

Not a referral pipeline and not a pharmacy preference. A better introduction. When a pharmacist calls and says your name and how long they have known you, the conversation starts with a person who has a history instead of a lead off a list. That is most of what the pharmacy side is worth to you.

All year, not just October

You will hear from us in February too.

Letters arrive. Drugs move tiers. A prior authorization gets denied. When that happens you call the same person who set your plan up, and we help you read it. That is the part most people never get.

Ask us anything

Questions about this, answered.

Will I get penalized for signing up for Medicare late?

Possibly, and it depends entirely on why you were late. If you had qualifying coverage the whole time, usually a group health plan through an employer with 20 or more employees, you generally will not owe a penalty.

If you simply did not enroll and had no creditable coverage, then yes. Part B adds 10 percent for every full twelve months you delayed and you pay it as long as you have Part B.

Part D adds 1 percent of the national base premium for every full month you went uncovered after 63 days without drug coverage.

How much is the Medicare Part B late enrollment penalty?

Ten percent of the standard Part B premium for each full twelve-month period you could have enrolled and did not. 50. It stays on your premium for life. Note that it counts full twelve-month periods, so a delay of 23 months is penalized at 10 percent, not 20.

How much is the Part D late enrollment penalty?

99 in 2026, for each full month you went without creditable drug coverage. 50 a month added to your plan premium and rounded to the nearest ten cents. It follows you even if you change plans, and the base premium it is calculated against changes each year.

How do I avoid a Medicare late enrollment penalty?

Enroll during your Initial Enrollment Period, or make sure you have creditable coverage every month you delay, and never let a gap run past 63 days. If you are working past 65 with employer coverage, confirm in writing that the drug coverage is creditable and keep that notice.

The single most common way people get penalized is using their full eight-month Part B window after employer coverage ends while missing the two-month window for a drug plan.

Does the Part A penalty last forever too?

No, and Part A is the exception in two ways. It is a flat 10 percent rather than 10 percent per year, and you pay it for twice the number of years you could have had Part A but did not enroll, then it stops.

It also only applies to people who do not qualify for premium-free Part A, which is a small minority, since most people earn premium-free Part A through about ten years of paying Medicare taxes.

Can a Medicare penalty be removed?

Sometimes. A Part D penalty can be reconsidered by Medicare's independent review contractor if you request it within 60 days of the letter, and proof of prior creditable coverage is the evidence that usually wins.

Qualifying for Extra Help stops the Part D penalty from being charged while you have it. Enrolling in a Medicare Savings Program eliminates the Part B penalty. Those last two are real and routinely missed.

Why is my Medicare premium higher than my friend's?

Usually one of two reasons, and they are completely different. Either a late enrollment penalty, which reflects when you signed up, or IRMAA, an income-related surcharge based on your tax return from two years ago.

IRMAA is not a penalty and enrolling on time would not have prevented it. If your income dropped because you retired, you can request a new determination, and a lot of people who qualify for that never file the form.

I got a letter saying I owe a penalty. What do I do?

Do not ignore it and do not just start paying it. Bring it to us, or call the number on the letter.

If it is a Part D penalty you have 60 days from the date on that letter to request a reconsideration, and the most useful thing you can dig up is any notice from a former employer or plan showing you had creditable drug coverage during the months in question.

Northern Colorado Medicare help

Bring your medication list. We will read it like pharmacists.

One appointment. Every medication priced tier by tier for the full year, your doctors looked up by name, and no pitch waiting at the end of it.

Ask us what a plan pays us and we will tell you the number. Haven is paid by the insurer if you enroll, and your premium is the same whether you use a broker or enroll directly.